Browse All Buxton NC Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Oceanfront in the heart of Buxton with a newly nourished beach right outside your door! Stones Throw is a unique duplex offering two separate living spaces and plenty of flexibility whether you are looking for a vacation rental, second home, or a place for family and friends to spread out. The upper level, known as Stones Throw Penthouse, features one bedroom, one full bath, kitchen, living area, and an oceanfront covered deck that is sure to be a favorite spot. Sit back with your morning coffee, listen to the waves, and take in those beautiful ocean views. The lower level offers two bedrooms, one full bath, kitchen, dining area, and living room. This space has a bright and fresh coastal feel with updated flooring, white walls, coastal trim details, recessed lighting, and ceiling fans. The kitchen offers plenty of cabinet and counter space, and the open living and dining area gives everyone room to gather after a day at the beach. There is also a washer and dryer conveniently located in the unit. Having two separate living spaces opens up so many possibilities. Use one and rent the other, give family and guests their own space, use the entire property as a vacation rental, or simply enjoy having a little extra room when everyone comes to the beach. The property is also serviced by a 4 bedroom septic system, adding even more flexibility for the future. And you cannot beat the Buxton location! You are close to the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse, Cape Point, beach driving access, some of the best fishing and surfing on Hatteras Island, local restaurants, shopping, tackle shops, and everything else Buxton has to offer. Head south and you are just a short drive from Frisco and Hatteras Village with marinas, ferry docks, and the Graveyard of the Atlantic Museum. Best of all, the beach in Buxton has just been nourished, giving Stones Throw a beautiful wide stretch of sand right out front. If you have been waiting for an oceanfront property on Hatteras Island with a flexible layout and a location that puts the beach front and center, this one is definitely worth a look.

46028 Cottage Avenue, Buxton

Listing courtesy of Midgett Realty - Rodanthe.

$449,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

You don't want to miss the old school Hatteras Island charm of this classic 4 bedroom, 2 bath oceanfront beach house in the heart of Buxton! And talk about timing! The beach in front of the home has just been renourished and looks absolutely amazing, giving you a gorgeous stretch of sand right outside your door. The real showstopper here is the oceanfront location. Head upstairs to the spacious top level living area where big Atlantic views immediately remind you why you came to Hatteras Island in the first place! Step outside onto the huge oceanfront deck and you may have a hard time going back inside. Grab your coffee for sunrise, spend the afternoon watching the waves roll in, or just kick back and enjoy the salty breeze. This is beach living the way it was meant to be! With four bedrooms and two baths, there is plenty of room for family and friends. The updated baths feature tiled walk in showers with glass surrounds, while the home's unique A frame inspired architecture, warm wood walls and laid back floor plan give it that fun, nostalgic beach house personality that is getting harder and harder to find. And then there is Buxton! Home to the iconic Cape Hatteras Lighthouse, this beloved Hatteras Island village puts so much close by. Pick up dinner at the local fish market, grab groceries, wander through the surf shops, art galleries and historic bookstore, or head out for pizza, fresh baked treats and plenty of local favorites. And, of course, some of the best parts of Hatteras Island, fishing, surfing, beach days and Cape Hatteras National Seashore, are right at your fingertips. If you have been waiting for a true oceanfront Buxton beach house with character, incredible views and a freshly renourished beach right out front, this is one you need to see. Bring the flip flops, grab the beach chairs and get ready for some serious porch sitting. Classic Hatteras Island beach living is waiting!

46017 S Tower Circle Road, Buxton

Listing courtesy of Midgett Realty - Rodanthe.

$449,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover comfort and convenience in this 3-bedroom, 1.5 bath ranch-style home located in the heart of Buxton, North Carolina. Nestled on a hight ridge in the X flood zone (no flood insurance required), this property offers peace of mind along with beautiful views of a tranquil canal. The home features stylish cork flooring throughout, adding warmth and sustainability to the interior. A 1-car garage provides additional storage or workspace. There is room for all your beach toys. Enjoy easy access to local shops, popular restaurants, and the stunning beaches of the Outer Banks. Plus, you're just minutes from the iconic Cape Hatteras Lighthouse. There is also deeded access to the sound right out the back door! Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, vacation retreat, or investment opportunity, this centrally located home offers the best of coastal living. Call you favorite Hatteras Island Realtor and schedule a tour today! Home inspection available.

49536 NC Highway 12, Buxton

Listing courtesy of Nc 12 Realty.

$494,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

If you're looking for a well-maintained, furnished and move-in ready home at the beach, this one is certainly a must see. Designed and built in 2004 for the sole owner, the home has been meticulously cared for and thoughtfully updated and maintained. High value recent improvements include a Fortified Roof (2021) using Corning Duration Designer shingles, new 3-ton energy-efficient HVAC (2025), fresh Sherwin Williams Duration exterior paint on Hardi plank siding, and a new French door GE refrigerator (2025). A 228 sq ft addition was completed in 2009, expanding and providing supplemental space in the primary suite. The home features propane with owner owned 57 gal tank for the stove, water heater, and dryer for efficiency and reducing electrical costs. Set on a 1.3-acre wooded lot with natural wildlife sedge in the back, the property offers privacy and space that’s hard to find while still being close to National Park Service facilities and the new multi-use pathway. Securely in the center of Buxton with a tree canopy providing for a quiet surrounding in a small welcoming neighborhood with paved roadways. A highly sought after quiet location that is off of the busy highway and on a separate cul-de-sac street. With only a short 5-step entry, the home offers easy access and comfortable single-floor living for any age. The wide 36" solid-core doors add to the home’s accessibility. The oversized and tall garage has plenty of room for beach gear, sporting equipment and tools, along with a built-in workbench. The dry entry from the garage leads into the shelved laundry room with front loading washer and dryer on pedestals. The screened porch (with Plexiglas inserts for cooler weather) is directly off the main living area accessible through large French doors for leisurely enjoyment and relaxation. Out back are multiple open deck spaces, plus a utility sink and a hot and cold outdoor shower to keep things tidy after the beach. Inside, the primary open great room living area features vaulted ceilings as well as 9 ft ceilings in the bedrooms. Oak wood floors run through the main living areas, with a tile floor in the kitchen area. The kitchen offers a sleek tall cabinet design with ample space and a gas range and oven with exhaust hood. Just off the living area is a convenient half bath, with two bedrooms and a full bath down the short hallway. The primary suite includes two spacious rooms, offering flexibility for an office, nursery, sitting area, or additional privacy. The master bathroom features a low-curb step-in shower with grab bars for easy entry. The currently configured office features customizable Elfa shelving and counters that can be easily adjusted to suit personal needs. There are many other details that include decorative and functional storm shutters, Cat 5 networking, TV cabling and telephone outlets in each room, outdoor wired security cameras, and a rainwater collection system with cistern pump for gardening, watering or washing . The home is being sold furnished and includes a fishing kayak, bikes, generator, chest freezer and many items in the garage that can be used for projects, maintenance or hobbies.

47155 Ridge Trail, Buxton

Listing courtesy of Nc 12 Realty.

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Buxton Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Buxton and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Browse All Buxton NC Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

Between $400K - $500K Buxton Real Estate

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?